blurben

Landlords · US

Normal Wear and Tear vs Damage: What Landlords Can Charge

By the Blurben team · · 6 min read

Normal wear and tear is the gradual decline that comes from living in a home the way it is meant to be lived in: faded paint, carpet worn thin along the hallway, a few small nail holes. Damage is harm caused by negligence, carelessness, accident or abuse: a gaping hole in the wall, a cigarette burn in the carpet, pet stains. The difference matters because in many US states a landlord may not keep any part of a security deposit to cover normal wear and tear, but may deduct the reasonable cost of repairing damage.

Below: how the law defines the two, a table of common examples, what three large states require at move-out, and a checklist for renters and landlords.

How the law defines normal wear and tear

There is no single federal definition. Each state sets its own rules, but the wording is often similar.

Texas defines normal wear and tear as "deterioration that results from the intended use of a dwelling," including breakage or malfunction due to age or deteriorated condition. It excludes deterioration that results from "negligence, carelessness, accident, or abuse" by the tenant, a member of the household or a guest (Texas Property Code, Section 92.001). Section 92.104 then states plainly that the landlord may not retain any portion of a security deposit to cover normal wear and tear.

California goes a step further. Its deposit law bars claims for conditions that existed before the tenancy, for ordinary wear and tear "whether the wear and tear preexisted the tenancy or occurred during the tenancy," and for the cumulative effects of wear and tear over one or more tenancies (California Civil Code, Section 1950.5).

The practical test: did this happen because someone lived in the home normally, over time? Then it is usually wear and tear. Was something misused, neglected or broken by accident? Then it is usually damage.

Wear and tear vs damage: common examples

The examples below come from guidance published by Ohio Legal Help and Idaho Legal Aid Services.

AreaUsually normal wear and tearUsually damage
WallsFaded, peeling or cracking paint; small nail holes, pin holes and minor nicksLarge holes or gouges; painting an unapproved color
CarpetWorn thin from walking; faded; light dirtBurns, rips, holes or pet stains
FloorsHardwood that is faded or needs a fresh coat of varnishChipped or gouged flooring
BathroomLoose grout; worn or scratched enamel in an old tub or sinkMissing or cracked tiles; chipped or broken enamel; a toilet damaged by improper use
Doors and windowsA door that sticks because of humidity or settlingA door ripped off its hinges; broken or missing windows
LocksRe-keying the lock between tenantsRe-keying because keys were lost or not returned
CleanlinessOrdinary dust from daily lifePet waste on floors or walls; pests caused by leaving garbage

Idaho Legal Aid adds that items reaching the end of their natural life during a tenancy, such as an old carpet, an aging appliance, light bulbs or a smoke detector battery, are not the tenant's cost just because they wore out on that tenant's watch. Ohio Legal Help notes that the longer someone lives in a place, the more wear and tear there will be, and that a tenant should not be charged for a replacement when a repair would do.

What a landlord must show when keeping part of a deposit

Rules on timing and paperwork differ by state. Here is how three large states handle it.

StateDeadline to return the depositWhat must come with any deduction
California21 calendar days after the tenant moves outAn itemized statement; for repairs or cleaning, photos and a written explanation of the cost (Civil Code 1950.5)
New York14 days after the tenant moves outAn itemized statement of the basis for any amount kept; a landlord who misses the deadline forfeits the right to keep any of it (NYC Rent Guidelines Board)
TexasOn or before the 30th day after the tenant surrenders the homeA written description and itemized list of all deductions (Property Code 92.103 and 92.104)

A few details stand out.

  • California photos. For tenancies that began on or after July 1, 2025, landlords must photograph the unit at the start of the tenancy. Since April 1, 2025, they must also photograph it after the tenant leaves but before repairs or cleaning, and again after the work is done.
  • California pre-move-out inspection. The tenant can ask for an initial inspection no earlier than two weeks before the tenancy ends, and receive a list of proposed deductions so they have a chance to fix the issues first.
  • New York inspections. According to the NYC Rent Guidelines Board, since November 15, 2025 these protections also extend to rent-stabilized tenants, including the right to an inspection before the tenancy ends and a chance to fix issues before moving out.
  • Texas burden of proof. If a tenant sues, the landlord has to prove that keeping the money was reasonable. A landlord who neither returns the deposit nor sends an itemized list within 30 days is presumed to have acted in bad faith. Texas also says a tenant may not withhold the last month's rent on the grounds that the deposit covers it.

For limits on deposit amounts and deadlines in other states, see our guide to security deposit laws by state.

A checklist to avoid deposit disputes

Most disagreements come down to one question: what did the home look like on day one? Good records answer it.

At move-in

  1. Walk through every room before you unpack and note every mark, stain and chip.
  2. Take dated photos or a video of each room, including floors, walls, appliances and fixtures. Our apartment viewing checklist covers what to look at.
  3. Fill in the move-in inspection form if you are given one, and keep a signed copy.

During the tenancy

  1. Report leaks and breakdowns in writing as soon as they happen, so there is a dated record.
  2. Ask in writing before painting, hanging heavy fixtures or making changes.

At move-out

  1. Ask for a walk-through or a pre-move-out inspection where your state offers one.
  2. Clean the home back to the condition it was in when you moved in.
  3. Take a fresh set of dated photos in the same order as at move-in.
  4. Return all keys and leave a forwarding address in writing.

For landlords

  1. Use the same photo routine at the start and end of every tenancy. In California it is a legal requirement.
  2. Charge only for damage beyond normal wear and tear, at a reasonable cost, and allow for the age of the item.
  3. Send the itemized statement before your state's deadline. Our first time landlord checklist covers the rest of the setup.

If you disagree with a deduction

Start by asking the landlord, in writing, for the itemized list and any photos or receipts behind each charge. In New York, the NYC Rent Guidelines Board says disputes over claimed damage generally go to small claims court, and complaints about deposits that were not returned can go to the New York State Attorney General. In other states, a local legal aid office can explain the options.

The short version

  • Wear and tear comes from normal living over time. Damage comes from negligence, accident or abuse.
  • In many states, including Texas and California, a landlord may not keep any part of a deposit for normal wear and tear.
  • Deadlines vary: 14 days in New York, 21 in California and 30 in Texas.
  • Dated photos at move-in and move-out are the best protection for both sides.

Sources: Texas Property Code, Chapter 92, California Civil Code, Section 1950.5, NYC Rent Guidelines Board: Security Deposits FAQs, Ohio Legal Help: What is reasonable wear and tear?, Idaho Legal Aid Services: What is normal wear and tear?.

Do it with Blurben

Moving in or moving out? Ask Blurben on WhatsApp or iMessage. Blurben is an AI real-estate companion that stays with you from finding the place, through the agreement and the move-in checklist, to connecting you with local services. Send Blurben your move-in photos and it can help you keep a clear record for the day you hand back the keys. More questions? See our FAQ.

This article is general information, not legal or financial advice. Rules change and differ by state and city, so check the official sources linked above for your location.

Frequently asked questions

What counts as normal wear and tear in a rental?

Deterioration from normal living over time, such as faded paint, small nail holes, carpet worn thin from walking and a door that sticks because of humidity.

Can a landlord deduct normal wear and tear from a security deposit?

In many states, no. Texas Property Code Section 92.104 says a landlord may not retain any portion of a deposit to cover normal wear and tear, and California Civil Code Section 1950.5 bars claims for ordinary wear and tear.

Is a hole in the wall wear and tear or damage?

Small nail holes and pin holes are usually treated as wear and tear. Large holes or gouges are usually treated as damage.

How long does a landlord have to return a deposit?

It depends on the state: 14 days in New York, 21 calendar days in California and 30 days in Texas.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax, financial or investment advice. Rules change and differ by location, so check with a licensed professional before you act.

Ask Blurben about your next property

An AI real estate companion on WhatsApp and iMessage, from finding the place through the agreement to connecting local services.